Wednesday, 10 February 2016

Behance WIP Feedback

As I wasn't too happy with the colour scheme yet, I desaturated my design and did a little sketch of Belgarath for the side to put up on Behance as a concept drawing for some peer feedback:

Belgarath (From "The Belgariad" - David Eddings) Concept. CAP Work.


·        
Sophie North
February 8, 2016 10:12 PM
EDIT: This is how I initially pictured Belgarath when reading the book, going back and looking at the text, I've just noticed wild inconsistencies between my version and how he is described.

Also I thought it might be helpful If you had a sample of the text, so:

"The storyteller, who seemed not to have a proper name as other men do, was a thoroughly disreputable old man. The knees of his hose were patched and his mismatched shoes were out at the toes. His long-sleeved woolen tunic was belted about the waist with a piece of rope, and his hood, a curious garment not normally worn in that part of Sendaria and one which Garion thought quite fine with its loosely fitting yoke covering shoulders, back and chest, was spotted and soiled with spilled food and drink. "
·         https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/user/50/b56cc925949145.56ab6e6498828.png
Sophie NorthFebruary 8, 2016 10:13 PM
TEXT CONTINUED: 

"Only his full cloak seemed relatively new. The old storyteller's white hair was cropped quite close, as was his beard. His face was strong, with a kind of angularity to it, and his features provided no clue to his background. He did not resemble Arend nor Cherek, Algar nor Drasnian, Rivan nor Tolnedran, but seemed rather to derive from some racial stock long since forgotten. His eyes were a deep and merry blue, forever young and forever full of mischief."
·         https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/user/50/5149725.53c1a46c3250a.jpg
Julia NilssonFebruary 8, 2016 10:57 PM
He looks really cool! I especially like the thoughtful expression you managed in the left hand sketch, maybe try and use that for the full figure as well? It's a really neat design though :) Only thing that I thought of when reading the text was that he's missing his cloak, but of course he could have taken it off. Good luck!
·         https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/user/50/17808311343609.56c9ba8c3afc5.png
Kevin MckennaFebruary 9, 2016 9:06 AM
It looks like a fantastic starting point, but I agree with some inconsistencies between the text and your original version. I think you have everything from the waist down spot on but at the moment he seems a bit too...homeless? for me anyway. Whilst I really like the overall shape of the facial sketch on the left he seems tired, quite unlike the forever young mischievous man the text describes. Maybe a more smug expression would do the trick? Just thoughts :) Your concept skills are very very nice though, keep it up! 
·         https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/user/50/b56cc925949145.56ab6e6498828.png
Sophie NorthFebruary 9, 2016 1:24 PM
@Kevin Mckenna I really agree, Its because in my head I was using descriptions that are also in the rest of the book as well-- but I do really wanna pin down a concept for the introductory description for my illustrations so you're 100% right. Thanks for taking the time to leave feedback too :3
·         https://mir-s3-cdn-cf.behance.net/user/50/b56cc925949145.56ab6e6498828.png
Sophie NorthFebruary 9, 2016 1:27 PM

@Julia Nilsson Yea, it's cause I was basing it on what I saw in my head after reading the whole book and not looking back at the initial description till after - oops! :P And I am gonna go back and add that cloak in so thanks for pointing it out!! I need to add in what other people who read the text are imagining too so the feedback is really helpful.

0 comments:

Post a Comment